This site uses cookies to improve your experience. To help us insure we adhere to various privacy regulations, please select your country/region of residence. If you do not select a country, we will assume you are from the United States. Select your Cookie Settings or view our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Cookie Settings
Cookies and similar technologies are used on this website for proper function of the website, for tracking performance analytics and for marketing purposes. We and some of our third-party providers may use cookie data for various purposes. Please review the cookie settings below and choose your preference.
Used for the proper function of the website
Used for monitoring website traffic and interactions
Cookie Settings
Cookies and similar technologies are used on this website for proper function of the website, for tracking performance analytics and for marketing purposes. We and some of our third-party providers may use cookie data for various purposes. Please review the cookie settings below and choose your preference.
Strictly Necessary: Used for the proper function of the website
Performance/Analytics: Used for monitoring website traffic and interactions
Jonathan, your post highlights an incredibly important and often overlooked issue in today’s real estate market: the proliferation of appraisal waivers and the resulting data cancer thats infecting property valuations. Sacramento Real Estate Appraiser 0
The brokers were difficult, espeically the “pre-comps”… but it was pretty cool getting paid at the door – in advance!! Everyone knew who the 2-3 crooked Appraisers were in the area, especially the MB’s. In the end the Appraisers I knew were cheating have taken their cash and moved on to better things.
I actually think the 4th appraisal used a couple superior comps in terms of quality of construction and 3 car garages. Appraisal 1 and 3 seemed decent. A lot of smaller GLA comps were used though in comparison to the subject. In reply to CRAIG PREECE. Yeah I saw that too.
Robinson appraiser is TK. It was also in a different neighborhood than the higher comps. Second appraiser used comps of fully renovated homes in an area which sells for a lot more because it’s revitalized. If the appraiser had a free attorney like the Plaintiff, appraiser would have won. Same reporter.
Except for the fact that the home inspection photos will also be analyzed and input in that database, along with all the appraisal photos from the properties you selected as comps, as they were once subject homes themselves. In reply to ej. Here comes the automation that the big fintechs are already using, now centralized.
Or maybe he lives in the heart of the city and takes elevators to provide appraisal services on perfect square boxes with plentiful comps, mere minutes away from the home office. 1-2 hours inspection and comps. Two and three a day appraisers using typing services, outsourcing, comps sharing, click and go pre write.
In other words you believe that if an appraiser is incompetent and utilizes wrong comps, data, etc. In reply to hammering hank. then he must be racist/biased! smh Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity 1
CU also has NOT visited the subject property nor the comparables and has not determined or provided evidence that the “comps” that are better than the ones initially provided in the report.
Some appraisers search purely by price or some other attribute that may not drive value. The smart ones identify the submarket and draw a continuous radius until they see the best 3 comps (we don’t need 6) – At this point you are visually studying the MLS descriptions to get the best. Let’s start at the basics.
Still in favor of the in person comps pictures requirements. Amc’s have taken advantage of these requirements, which is why a substantial portion of simple appraisal work has now been shifted over to realty persons instead. Quite often so is taking photos of comps in the same high density housing areas.
Can’t the appraiser recognize that using two-year-old sales comp’s have meaning and be part of the value conclusion? When these two figures are sorted, they represent stuff, which can be interpreted and verified as meaningful or not. Did it close in 45 days or in ten months?
One appraiser’s vision of the (near) future: Imagine having your own privately hosted Large Language Model (LLM) or soon-to-debut Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) model. This in-house appraisal tool will input and analyze all your photos, on-site video footage, and LiDAR measured dwelling information. How much money you will make!
An appraisal is an opinion (among other things) of … Scope of Work The contract The neighborhood The site, including H & BU The improvements (condition, deficiencies, adverse conditions and conformity) The selection and adjustment of comparable sales The analysis of prior subject and comp sales Market Value indicated by the Sales Comparison (..)
The appraisal reports included are not from this Connelly/Motts v Lanham case. 3 comps and 1 active leave little ground to stand solidly on in court. Is there any means that we can get those to review? I’m glad I’m not having to defend such work.
As far as I understand it, when an ROV is submitted to you by the lender, who may have received it from the borrower, they have to give you a valid and researched reason as to why their comp(s) is worthy of being considered and is better than your comp(s). This according to Dodd-Frank & the revised ROV rule.
A picture is worth a thousand words but an in person visit (subject/comps) is worth a million. I had a comp in a neighborhood I was well familiar with and after viewing the listing photos I yelled at the agent (in my head of course) where the hell are the pictures of the mountains the house was facing. She had not included one.
They must include a fee for appraisers to do ROVs. I’ve done some that have taken a couple of hours because they included many comps. I have to fully research each comp to determine if it’s a true comp or not. I even had one AMC tell me I should go drive by the new comps provided.
Appraiser who start out with a blank canvas (so to speak), with no asking price information provided to them, — obtaining data only by available visual information and records of the property and improvements itself, to work up the estimate and appropriate comps. In reply to Spencer Paul.
Ralphy is busy making $300 per appraisal and thinks he’s getting rich. He should be earning $700 to $1,200 per appraisal. I wouldn’t take comp photos and make a trip to the county records office for $300. In reply to Spencer Paul.
An appraiser just asked for help in an older thread. FNMA forcing a repurchase and subsequent state complaint because appraiser cross comped across a school district boundary a half mile away. [link] The hits keep on coming.
Any good appraiser is already explicitly explaining their comp search, includes a farm list AND discusses specific sales not used that someone might wonder about. How bout a requirement that the underwriter screen any ROV before automatically sending it to the appraiser?
Do work that other appraiser’s are not willing to do because they want to cherry pick work that are located in a single county that they live in and don’t have to drive more then 20 minutes for the subject and comps. This is going to be the market for sometime, of which I do agree with you. Expand and find new clients.
There are several filing forms involved and depending on the existing documentation, owners may need to engage with a certified business appraiser to independently declare a final value for tax purposes. In many cases, this would be tangible property only, such as real estate, buildings, machinery & equipment, and personal property.
The comps/market and analysis speaks for itself. Is the analysis sound, are the comps conditionally and locationally adequate and relevant to the subject. Who’s concerned about ethnicity or race and how can one appraise a property on that basis? It’s not the appraisers who request that photos of people, ethnic art, etc.
…a brilliant ‘work around’ to solve the subject & comps adjustment issues, which Fannie Mae thinks is no big deal… Appraisers, I was chatting with an appraiser buddy last week about the ANSI measuring dilemma we all face when doing Conventional lending reports, which ultimately will wind up with Fannie Mae.
This extends beyond just the comps in your grid to every single comparable in your model. I use True Adjustmnet Trends from Homeputer. Remarkably, it doesn’t require photos to assess and rate the condition and quality of comparables.
We organize all of the trending information in your field so you don't have to. Join 8,000+ users and stay up to date on the latest articles your peers are reading.
You know about us, now we want to get to know you!
Let's personalize your content
Let's get even more personalized
We recognize your account from another site in our network, please click 'Send Email' below to continue with verifying your account and setting a password.
Let's personalize your content